It perhaps is the right time, in light of current developments and deliberations, to share a few thoughts on what I would like to describe as the Davidian dilemma. The term ‘Davidian’ as utilized is in reference to the psalmist David, who has been a favorite character of many Bible students throughout the centuries.

The fifty-first Psalm provides us with a touching record of David’s heartfelt repentance after being confronted concerning his heinous act of depriving Uriah of his wife and life. It is a sordid, sobering and shocking story that is left on sacred record from which we may learn important lessons about God and about ourselves, as we progress in our personal pilgrimage toward the Promised Land. Indeed, it should not surprise any of us to find these historical “ensamples” repeating themselves in the experience of God’s people “upon whom the ends of the world are come” (1 Corinthians 10:11 KJV).

It is not the purpose of this post to provide a detailed exposition of the Psalm, as it does little in improving on the work of Charles Spurgeon, Matthew Henry or the many other illustrious commentators whose writings are available for our enlightenment, edification and enjoyment. The purpose is to highlight practical lessons that can be helpful for personal application from David’s story. Consideration is also given to whether David’s post-transgression attitude was characterized by shameless audacity or whether it was shaped by a sense of spiritual obligation to those within his immediate and wider circles of influence.

Psalm 51:5 is often used by defenders of the Augustinian doctrine of ‘original sin’ (which affirms that all human beings incur guilt from Adam’s fall) and is presented as evidence for the purported validity of this teaching. However, careful, intelligent scholarship and proper exegesis never permit us to use one Bible verse to create a doctrine, while ignoring other biblical content which address the subject! A thorough reading of this Psalm will reveal that there is absolutely no support here for the concept of ‘original sin’. This is nothing but another of the enemy’s “cunningly devised fables” to lead careless, unsuspecting and simplistic souls astray. 

David’s statement that “I was shapen in iniquity; and in sin did my mother conceive me” was not intended to communicate the idea that because of innate corruption received from the moment of conception, he had no choice but to do what he did! In reality, he lamented the choices he made, and bemoaned the sinful circumstances into which he was born. It was never his intention, however, to point to these circumstances as justification for his predicament or as a pretext for any future departure from the will of God. His repentance and his impassioned appeal to God for cleansing provide ample evidence that he believed in the possibility of complete restoration and reformation of life. 

The power and the privilege of God’s gift of repentance is another salient point to consider. In Romans 2:4 we are told that it is God’s goodness that leads us to repentance. When an individual who is in the public spotlight, such as David, falls into blatant sin as he did, the natural impulse is often to attempt to conceal the matter and carry on as though it did not happen. In religious organizations leadership sometimes seek to redeem individuals through a carefully arranged change of scenario that removes the guilty from the “crime scene” to another location where they hope they can continue life or ministry away from critical eyes and inquiring minds that might demand accountability. 

At times this approach might appear to be successful. However, if repentance and true conversion are not experienced, the result is a self-deception which only creates injury to the individual and to the cause of Christ. The wiser, though admittedly more difficult course of action is to accept the reality of one’s failure and to place the whole matter in the hands of God, humbly recognizing the injury inflicted upon His righteous cause as a consequence of the misdeed. David eventually benefitted from choosing this latter approach, albeit with some help from Nathan the prophet, whose tactful but direct treatment of the issue led the broken-hearted king to humble himself before the Lord in noble and exemplary penitence.

There is a deep relief and profound peace that comes with genuine confession and repentance that is known only to the individual who experiences it. Indeed, as David exclaims, “blessed is he whose transgression is forgiven, whose sin is covered. Blessed is the man unto whom the Lord imputeth not iniquity, and in whose spirit there is no guile” Psalm 32:1, 2. Evidently, the man “in whose spirit there is no guile” is not necessarily the pious onlooker who has never fallen into public disgrace, but rather the one who may have fallen but deals honestly with the reality of the situation and faithfully repents. 

In addition to this, the blessing denoted in this verse includes the gift of patience and forbearance that one is able to exercise when confronted by the malice, mischaracterization, mistreatment and mischief of those who are determined to not forget the sinful act that was committed by the errant child of God. We need to understand that as long as we live in this sinful world, Satan will inspire individuals to rejoice at the demise of others and find creative and subtle ways to remind them of their failures at every opportunity. This, unfortunately, is a simple fact of life. The practical counsel to everyone who falls into such a situation is to steadfastly ignore those derisive voices and focus on the promises of God! One such promise is found in Micah 7:8, which says, “Do not rejoice over me, my enemy; when I fall, I will arise; when I sit in darkness, the Lord will be a light to me.”

The section of David’s prayer that has really caught my attention more than anything else in Psalm 51 says; “Create in me a clean heart, O God; and renew a right spirit within me. Cast me not away from thy presence; and take not thy holy spirit from me. Restore unto me the joy of thy salvation; and uphold me with thy free spirit” (verses 10-12).

Notice the requests that the repentant king makes of God. He asks for a clean heart and a right spirit. He asks not to be cast away from God’s presence. This is important, as in too many cases the default response towards persons who find themselves in similar circumstances is precisely that—to cast them away! David’s petition to the Lord was that the Holy Spirit not be taken away from him. He asks that the joy of salvation be restored in his heart and that he be upheld, that is, kept from falling again, by the power of the Spirit. Evidently, had David not been convinced that these things were possible he would not have prayed in this manner. This amazing prayer alludes to the wonderful possibilities available to the repentant soul!

One can only imagine the joy and relief experienced by David with the assurance that his prayers of confession and repentance were accepted by God. Yet this is where the dilemma of which we speak comes in. What should David’s course be, now that God has graciously pardoned his sins? He can take one of two roads: the first would be to cherish a grateful spirit, but lay low, especially with the consciousness of the public nature of his mistake which brought much injury to the cause of God. The second is to do the very opposite and testify publicly to the power of God while warning others not to make similar choices as he made. 

Verse 13 tells us of David’s decision: “Then will I teach transgressors thy ways; and sinners shall be converted unto thee.” The verse tells us that David got another opportunity to serve, which he gladly embraced. This is a most remarkable statement, because David’s redemption by God is not the approach that some today would take. There are those who side with the position that any public service or missionary work for God by David ought to have ended with his fall from grace, notwithstanding his repentance. But this is not what we find in Scripture! David obviously understood that after humbling himself before God in true confession and repentance there was a further duty that he had, which was to teach others the lessons he learned by taking a humble but decided stand against sin and guiding others into the path of righteousness. This was not a shameless audacity on the part of David, but a serious and moral duty enjoined upon him by God Himself. While many try to keep their deviance a secret and still desire to continue in the public domain while dishonoring God, David made his confession, spoke about his experience publicly, obtained forgiveness of the Lord and used his journey as an object lesson for others.

Throughout the Scriptures this principle is seen in operation. Whereas Satan delights in leading those who profess the name of Christ to commit grievous sins that bring dishonor to God’s cause and reproach to the name of Jesus, God delights in taking these very ones and revealing through them His power to save from sin. More than this, however, He then uses them as ambassadors of His Kingdom to turn around and wreak havoc upon the kingdom of Satan by witnessing mightily to His truth and rescuing souls from the very evils by which they were formerly ensnared! How about that! One can readily think of one of Jesus’ own followers—Peter— to whom He said, “when thou art converted, strengthen thy brethren.” After a most shocking denial of his Master, that very man was found a few weeks later, transformed and filled with the Holy Ghost, and a fearless proponent of present truth! A number of other examples could be cited as evidence of this remarkable work of grace.

One can only imagine how Satan feels about such a transaction, and it is not a surprise to hear those under his influence repeat statements along the lines of the following: “Isn’t that David, the man who took Uriah’s wife and murdered him in cold blood to try to cover it up? Why is he still writing songs and talking to people about sin? Is he for real? We all know his story! Wouldn’t it be better for him to quietly go back to Bethlehem and restart his sheep farming business? By the way, did you hear that Bathsheba is now his wife, and they are planning to make their son Solomon king after David? Can anything be more barefaced than this? What a hypocrite!” 

This is the spirit that will always be found in those who are tutored by Satan and are ignorant of the transforming power of God’s grace. These are they to whom the Lord declares, “Ye do err, not knowing the scriptures, nor the power of God” Matthew 22:29. But all who are willing to humble themselves under the mighty hand of God, accept His chastisement and submit to His molding, will bear witness in life and word to the redemptive power of the gospel. May the example of this great “man after God’s own heart” inspire and encourage all who like him, have come under the attack of the destroyer of souls. Let all remember that Jesus Christ, who has adopted the title “Son of David,” takes joy in saving the repentant soul from his/her sins, no matter how terrible. It is the sinner’s privilege to lay hold of this offer of mercy and accept the gracious pardon and power so abundantly provided through Christ.

Perhaps the clearest presentation of the thesis of this article is found in the following words of David himself: “I waited patiently for the Lord; and he inclined unto me, and heard my cry. He brought me up also out of an horrible pit, out of the miry clay, and set my feet upon a rock, and established my goings. And he hath put a new song in my mouth, even praise unto our God: many shall see it, and fear, and shall trust in the Lord” Psalm 40:1-3.

Christ Himself has reminded us that those who have benefitted most from His grace have a greater responsibility to share it with others. “For everyone to whom much is given, from him much will be required; and to whom much has been committed, of him they will ask the more” Luke 12:48. The most powerful testimonies in Heaven will come from the lips of those who were once zealous in doing Satan’s work but were plucked as brands from the fire and serve Jesus with deep devotion and unwavering fervency. 

God’s inspired messenger wrote: “The gospel is to be presented, not as a lifeless theory, but as a living force to change the life. God desires that the receivers of His grace shall be witnesses to its power. Those whose course has been most offensive to Him He freely accepts; when they repent, He imparts to them His divine Spirit, places them in the highest positions of trust, and sends them forth into the camp of the disloyal to proclaim His boundless mercy” Ellen G. White, The Desire of Ages, p. 826 (emphasis supplied).

In light of these things, well might one exclaim with the former murderer and persecutor, Saul of Tarsus: “…woe is unto me, if I preach not the gospel!” 1 Corinthians 9:16. Ridicule, suspicion, slander and scorn will result from every such effort, but these are small matters when weighed against a warning like this. The power of Christ to redeem, renew and restore must be proclaimed by all those who have been its chief beneficiaries.

Don R. West, DDiv, is a Christian author and apologist who writes from Chicago, Illinois. To access his latest book, ‘The Message and the Mission’ click here.
Spread the love